fall & winter pre-order menu
Welcome to the Fall/Winter baked goods menu!
This is a menu of our goodies that are available to pre-order October through March. Please note that we do not carry our full menu in the case every day; to see what we’re baking right now, please check this week’s menu.
Click the
icon to see a photo of the item!
Whole cakes and pies as well as orders over 3 dozen must be ordered in advance; please see our special ordering info. Thanks!
Cakes and Cupcakes
Ordering Information for Cakes:
8″ round cake is $30, unless otherwise noted, and feeds about 10-14 people.
6″ round cake is $20 (only available in flavors marked with asterisk) and feeds 4-6.
Ordering Information for Cupcakes:
Cupcakes must be pre-ordered by the dozen per flavor, however flavors marked with asterisk (first six flavors on menu) may be ordered in any quantity as we make them every day. Cupcakes are $1.60 each.
Miniature cupcakes are available in the flavors marked with an asterisk (first six flavors listed) for $8.50 per dozen. They are super cute cocktail-sized and we recommend them for school parties and other fun events. These delightful wee morsels are not carried in the bakery and are only available by pre-order.
Flavors listed are available as either cake or cupcake unless specified otherwise.
- Capote*…
chocolate cake with white buttercream icing and white sprinkles - Frankly Scarlett*… $35
red velvet cake with rich cream cheese icing - Plain Jane*…
classic vanilla cake with our fabulous vanilla buttercream icing (pre-orders: icing will be white unless otherwise specified) - Prozac*…
chocolate cake with smooth chocolate buttercream icing - Pucker Up*…
sweet and tart lemon layer cake with lemon icing - The Classic*…
vanilla cake with chocolate icing - Cindy Lou Who… $40
cake only, three layer vanilla cake (layers colored pink, yellow, and lavender) with pink buttercream icing and polka dots - Sam I Am… $40 cake only, three layer vanilla cake (layers colored blue, yellow, and lavender) with blue buttercream icing and polka dots
- Here Comes Trouble… $35 cake only, caramel cake with caramel icing
- Irish Car Bomb… $35 cake only, like the popular bar beverage! chocolate-Guinness extra stout cake with Bailey’s buttercream icing (the icing does contain a small amount of alcohol)
- Presto Cake… $20
for an 8×8 pan of chocolate cake with peanut butter glaze-like icing, this cake is not a showpiece, but you just can’t stop eating it - Grasshopper…
chocolate cake with pale green peppermint icing - Strawberry Fields Forever… strawberry cake + strawberry icing
- Lindye’s Cake… $35 cake only; broiled coconut and pecan chocolate cake that is unlike anything you’ve ever eaten. Delicious!
- Mocha Madness…
chocolate cake with mocha buttercream icing - Mopsy… $35 ginger carrot cake with cream cheese icing and pecans
- Oodelolly… $35
vanilla cake w/coconut filling, old-fashioned boiled icing, & coconut topping - Pink Lady… cupcake only
chocolate cupcake with strawberry icing - Snickerdoodle… cinnamon brown sugar cake with cinnamon buttercream icing
- The King…
banana-pecan cake with peanut butter icing - Tomboy…
chocolate cake with peanut butter icing - Autumn Apple… $35 cake only. apple-spice cake layers with cream cheese-honey icing
- Pumpkin D’light… delicious pumpkin cake with cream cheese icing
- Caramel Apple… $35 cake only, apple-spice layers with brown sugar caramel icing
Cookies and Bars
Minimum order of two dozen for special order, except for asterisk flavors
- Chocolate Chip Cookie*… $.50
available w/ pecans by special order - Classic Brownie… $1
- Coconut Macaroon… $.65

- Elizabeth’s Sugar Cookie… $.50
- Espresso Brownie… $1
with espresso in the brownie and espresso glaze - Ginger Kip… $.60
crunchy oatmeal ginger cookies - Apple Pecan Oat Bar… $1 apple jam bar with toasty pecans and oats
- Hello Dolly Bar… $1
total sin. Graham cracker, chocolate, coconut, pecans - Jan’s Famous Toffee Bar*… $.60
crisp cookie bottom, chocolate and pecans on top! try with vanilla ice cream! - Lindye’s Honey Rosemary Cookie … $.50
these were featured in the Memphis Flyer! Yay Lindye! - Double Chocolate Sea Salt Cookie… $.50 chocolatey goodness with flecks of sea salt make for a fabulous grown up chocolate cookie
- Gingerbread Molasses Cookie… $.50 soft and flavorful, ginger and spice mixed with molasses
- Minty brownie… $1 chocolate brownie with a layer of mint icing on top; these were featured in Evey Day with Rachael Ray!
- Oatmeal Coconut Cookie… $.50
chewy and delicious - Oatmeal Raisin Cookie… $.50
a delicious classic - Tammy’s Sweet n Salty Cookie… $.50 delicious butterscotch and pecan chewy cookie
- Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie*… $.50
the best ever
Pies
10″ pies with a light, flaky house-made crust. Baby pies (cupcake size) are available in the asterisk flavors for $25/dozen. Yum!
- Bananarama… $24
totally rad banana cream pie - Chocolate Dream… $24 diner-style chocolate ice box pie
- Cocoa Chanel… $20
classic chocolate chess pie - Kick in the Pants… $20 tart lemon butter pie
- Johnny Appleseed… $24 double crust apple pie with spices
- Nancy’s Boy*… $20
coconut chess - Shady Wake*… $20
delicious Southern pecan
Fall/winter pies (still dependent on seasonal availability!):
- Punkin’ Pie*… $20
pumpkin and spice pie - Cherry Baby*… $24 cherry lattice-crust pie
- Sweet Patootie… $20
sweet potatoes and spices - Brad’s Apple Pie… $24 apples & spices with sharp cheddar baked into crust
- Pear Gruyere… $24 pears and honey with gruyere cheese baked into the crust
- Tollhouse Jack… $20 chocolate chip cookie-like filling spiked with whisky
- Old-Fashioned Buttermilk… $20
smooth buttermilk pie with a touch of nutmeg
Muffins and Breads
Eight inch loaf… $12 Muffins… $12/dozen.
- Dreamboat… $26
10 inch orange bundt cake with a citrus glaze - Banana Blitzkrieg
muffin or loaf, banana-pecan deliciousness - Cranberry Orange, muffin or loaf
- Muddy’s Wheat Germ
muffin only, must be ordered at least 4 days in advance!!! - Pear – Pecan, muffin or loaf
- Pumpkin – Pecan, muffin or loaf
- Perky Poppyseed, muffin or loaf
- Banana Espresso Chocolate Chip, muffinonly
Click the
icon to see a photo of the item!
Some items contain nuts; we have tried to indicate if an item has nuts, however if you are concerned about the presence of nuts please ask at the time you place your order. Please be aware that we do use nuts in the bakery and cannot guarantee that an item without nuts is completely free of trace elements. It’s nuts!
