If you had something in the shop and it isn’t on this menu,
don’t despair! Ask us for it.
We are constantly experimenting and being creative
with flavor combos and our written menu just can’t keep up!
Prices in the shop:
Cupcakes… $1.50 each
Cookies… $.50 each
Slices of cake… $5 each
Slices of pie… $3.50-$4.50 each (single crust; double crust)
Thin bars (toffee, lime bars, etc)… $.60
Thick bars (brownies, lemon squares, hello dollies, etc)… $.85
Side of icing (for dipping)… $.60
Muffins (when available)… $1.00
Lunch prices:
We don’t have a set lunch menu- we change it all the time!
The Thomas… $6.00 our now-famous pimiento cheese BLT on whole wheat; daily!
Daily Sammies… $6.00 (includes side item)
Soup … bowl $4.50 cup (dine-in only) $2.50
Our Menu!
Please note that we do not carry our full menu every day and that whole cakes and pies must be ordered in advance: please place your order two business days in advance. Thanks!
Click the 
for a picture of your favorite Muddy's treat!
Cakes
Layer cakes are two 8 inch layers unless stated otherwise.
Plain Jane…$30 classic vanilla cake with our fabulous vanilla buttercream icing
Prozac…$30 
chocolate cake with smooth chocolate buttercream icing
Capote… $30 chocolate cake with white buttercream icing and white sprinkles
Pucker Up…$30 sweet and tart lemon layer cake with lemon icing
Jim’s Darn Cake…$30 
chocolate cake with flavorful chocolate & orange icing
Oodelolly…$35 
coconut cake with special glaze between layers and
old-fashioned boiled icing
Mocha Madness…$30 
chocolate cake with mocha buttercream icing
Hubba Hubba…$30 
lemon coconut cake; a tangy twist on a favorite
Frankly Scarlett…$35 classic red velvet cake with rich cream cheese icing
Daisy…$30 
lemon cake with white vanilla buttercream icing
Forty Carrots…$35 
citrus-y carrot cake iced with cream cheese icing
Cindy Lou Who…$40 
3 layer vanilla cake (layers colored pink, yellow, and lavender) iced with pink buttercream icing and decorated in polka dots
Strawberry Fields Forever…$30 
strawberry cake with strawberry icing
Monkey Around…$30 banana cake with pecans and banana icing
Presto Cake…$20 for an 8x8 pan 
Chocolate with peanut butter glaze-like icing, this cake is not a showpiece, but you just can’t stop eating it
Dreamboat…$26 
10 inch orange bundt cake with a citrus glaze
Perky Poppy…$26 
10 inch poppy-seed bundt cake with a lemon kick
Icings: vanilla (variety of pastels), chocolate, mocha, strawberry, lemon,
peach, orange, peppermint, rose water, lavender, old-fashioned boiled …
Cookies and Bars
minimum order of a dozen for special order
Best Chocolate Chip…$.50 
also available w/ pecans
Jan’s Famous Toffee Bars…$.60 
a Christmas favorite for years
Ginger Kips…$.60 
crunchy, chewy, zesty bar cookies with a real ginger kick!
Ultimate Peanut Butter…$.50 
the best ever
Oatmeal Raisin…$.50 a soft and chewy classic
Oatmeal Coconut…$.50 
chewy and delicious
Anne’s Life-Saving Lime Bars… $.60 mmmmmmmmmmm!
Therapy Brownies… $.85 brownies with white chocolate and pecans
Classic Brownies… $.85 classic, chocolate brownies
Hello Dollies… $.85 
total sin. Graham cracker, chocolate, coconut, pecans.
Pies
All 10” piecrusts have a light, flaky crust. Yum!
Sweet Patootie…$20 
sweet potatoes and spices
Nancy’s Boy…$20 
coconut chess
Peachy Keen…$24 fresh peaches and cream (seasonal)
Shady Wake…$20 
delicious Southern pecan
Berry Merry Pie…$24 
strawberries and raspberries atop chocolate mousse
Kick in the Pants Pie…$20 tart lemon butter pie
Bananarama…$24 
totally rad banana cream pie
Old-Fashioned Buttermilk… $20 smooth buttermilk pie with a touch of nutmeg
Cocoa Chanel…$20 classic chocolate chess pie
Cupcakes
Just like our delicious cakes, but in a smaller package.
Special order minimum is a dozen cupcakes per flavor. $1.50 each
Plain Jane 
classic vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream icing
Prozac 
chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream icing
Pucker Up 
sweet and tart lemon cupcake with lemon icing
Jim’s Darn Cake chocolate cupcake with chocolate-orange icing
Oodelolly vanilla cupcake with old-fashioned icing and coconut topping
Mocha Madness 
chocolate cake with mocha buttercream icing
Capote 
chocolate cake with white vanilla icing and white sprinkles
Tomboy chocolate cupcake with peanut butter icing
Grasshopper chocolate cupcake with pale green mint icing
Hubba Hubba lemon cupcake, lemon icing, coconut topping
Frankly Scarlett red velvet cupcake with rich cream cheese icing
White Tie 
chocolate cupcake with old-fashioned boiled icing and coconut topping
Daisy lemon cake with white vanilla buttercream icing
Forty Carrots 
citrus-y carrot cupcake iced with tangy cream cheese icing
Muffins and Breads
A loaf of bread is 8”.
Blueberry Muffins…$1
Muddy’s Wheat Germ Muffins…$1 
everyone’s favorite! Must be ordered at least 4 days in advance!!!
Cranberry Orange Bread…$12 zippy and delicious!
Banana Blitzkrieg Bread (with or without pecans)…$12 