Pie of the Month Subscription

The Delicious Details

What's that, a Muddy's pie subscription? Indeed! Choose from a 3-, 6-, or 12- month subscription of our scratch-made, all-butter crust pies. Perfect for a scrumptious gift, monthly family dinners, or pre-scheduled personal consumption. We feature our beloved classics (I'm looking at you, Shady Wake!) as well as ones specific to their season (hello, fresh fruit pies!).

Subscriptions will start the month after purchase (or later if you want!) and will be for consecutive months with pick-ups on a Wednesday of your choice.

One of our gnomies will follow up by phone to confirm the details of your subscription, including dates, pick up location, and recipient's info if planning to give as a gift! Please include best contact number in the "Special Instructions" section.

Check out the drool-worthy pie by month breakdown:

  • January- Johnny Appleseed 
  • February- Cocoa Crackle
  • March- Coconut Cloud 
  • April- Key Lime 
  • May- Strawberry Honey 
  • June: Blueberry Crumble
  • July: Jumbleberry
  • August: Chocolate Dream
  • September: Shady Wake
  • October: Nancy's Boy
  • November: Pumpkin Five Spice
  • December: Peppermint Patty