Skip to content
Online orders need at least 2 days' notice. Need something quick? Walk-in or call during open hours!
Common Questions
Search
My Account
0
Basket
Pre-Order Online
Show me EVERYTHING!
Easter Specials
Signature Cakes
Decorated Cakes
Cupcakes
Pies & Puddin'
Cookies & More
For Your Freezer
Gifts, etc
Shop In-Store
Classes & Events
Classes, Events & Parties
Baking Classes FAQ
Terms & Conditions for Events
Buy Tickets to an Event
About Muddy's
How it all works now!
Work at Muddy's
Treat Truck
FAQ
Help & Info
Take & Bake Instructions
How to Store Baked Goods
Blog
FAQ
Contact Us
Pre-Order Online
Show me EVERYTHING!
Easter Specials
Signature Cakes
Decorated Cakes
Cupcakes
Pies & Puddin'
Cookies & More
For Your Freezer
Gifts, etc
Shop In-Store
Classes & Events
Classes, Events & Parties
Baking Classes FAQ
Terms & Conditions for Events
Buy Tickets to an Event
About Muddy's
How it all works now!
Work at Muddy's
Treat Truck
FAQ
Help & Info
Take & Bake Instructions
How to Store Baked Goods
Blog
FAQ
Contact Us
Take a Class
Read Our Blog
Hi, you really need javascript to navigate this site on mobile devices.
Home
All Products
All Products
Plain Jane Cake
From $37.00
Shady Wake Pie
$29.00
Prozac Cupcakes
From $18.50
Jan's Famous Toffee Bark
$9.00
Plain Jane Cupcakes
From $18.50
Deluxe Chocolate Chip Cookies
From $6.75
Brown Butter Crispy Rice Treats
From $7.50
Cocoa Crackle Pie
$25.00
Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookies
From $6.75
Nancy's Boy Pie
$29.00
St. Patty's Sprankle Cookies: March Special
From $6.75
Double Chocolate Brownies: Easter Special
From $12.00
Banana Puddin'
$30.00
Oatmeal Cream Pies: March Special
From $11.75
Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars
From $6.75
Coconut Macaroons
$11.25
Take & Bake Savory Quiche
From $30.00
Apricot Jammy Bars: Easter Special
From $9.00
Coconut Cloud Pie: Easter Special
$29.00
Tollhouse Jack Pie
$33.00
Kick in the Pants Pie
$25.00
Strawberry Fields Forever Cupcakes
From $18.50
Classic Cupcakes
From $18.50
Grasshopper Cupcakes: March Special
From $18.50
Vanilla Bean Wafers
$7.25
Irish Cream & Beer Cupcakes: March Special
From $18.50
Prozac Cake
From $37.00
Truman Capote Cupcakes
From $18.50
Truman Capote Cake
From $37.00
Strawberry Fields Forever Cake
From $39.00
Classic Cake
From $37.00
Grasshopper Cake: March Special
From $37.00
Muddy's Gift Card
From $10.00
Cotton Tail Cake: Easter Special
From $46.00
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies
From $6.75
Peppermint Patrick Pie: March Special
$29.00
Iced Shamrock Cookies: March Special
From $12.75
Oatmeal Everything Cookies
From $7.75
Sprankle Surprise Cupcakes
From $18.50
Sprankle Surprise Cake
From $39.00
Oreo Puddin'
$30.00
Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription
From $68.00
DIY Cupcake Kit
$22.00
Take & Bake: Chicken Pot Pie
$30.00
Muddy's Drinkware
From $16.00
Take & Bake: All-Butter Crust
$10.00
Take & Bake Seasonal Fruit Crisp
From $17.00
Muddy's Baking Mixes
From $10.00
Take & Bake Cookies
From $17.00
Muddy's Tee Shirt- retro logo on green
$25.00
1
2
3
Next »