Kat's Christmas Favorites – Muddy's Bake Shop

Online orders need at least 2 days' notice. Need something quick? Walk-in or call during open hours!

November & December Menu

We're baking up the very best of our menu for this season of thanks and joy! We'll be open our normal hours with special hours during the holiday weeks:

NORMAL HOURS: OPEN Wed/Thu/Fri 10a-5:30p + Saturday 10a-4p

Special Thanksgiving Week Hours: OPEN Tue 11/25 + Wed 11/26 10a-4p ... CLOSED Thu-Sat

Special Christmas Week Hours: OPEN Tue 12/23 + Wed 12/24 10a-4p ... CLOSED Dec 25 - Jan 1

Happy Holiday Season! xx, the Muddy's gnomies

Reindeer Bundt Cake (Dec Only)

Reindeer Bundt Cake (Dec Only)

Regular price $45.00

Regular price Sale price $45.00
Unit price per
Peppermint Patty Pie (Dec Only)

Peppermint Patty Pie (Dec Only)

Regular price $30.00

Regular price Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Family Favorites Cookie Platter (Dec Only)

Sold out

Family Favorites Cookie Platter (Dec Only)

Regular price From $43.00

Regular price Sale price From $43.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Santa Baby Cupcakes (Dec Only)

Santa Baby Cupcakes (Dec Only)

Regular price From $20.50

Regular price Sale price From $20.50
Unit price per
Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Regular price $30.00

Regular price Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake

Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake

Regular price From $105.00

Regular price Sale price From $105.00
Unit price per
Santa Baby Cake (Dec Only)

Santa Baby Cake (Dec Only)

Regular price From $37.00

Regular price Sale price From $37.00
Unit price per
Shady Wake Pie

Shady Wake Pie

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Prozac Cake

Prozac Cake

Regular price From $37.00

Regular price Sale price From $37.00
Unit price per
Prozac Cupcakes

Prozac Cupcakes

Regular price From $20.50

Regular price Sale price From $20.50
Unit price per
Mini Cupcakes

Mini Cupcakes

Regular price $18.00

Regular price Sale price $18.00
Unit price per
Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription

Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription

Regular price From $85.00

Regular price Sale price From $85.00
Unit price per
Muddy's Gift Card

Muddy's Gift Card

Regular price From $10.00

Regular price Sale price From $10.00
Unit price per
Gingerbread Folks (Dec Only)

Gingerbread Folks (Dec Only)

Regular price From $12.75

Regular price Sale price From $12.75
Unit price per
Christmas Sprankle Cookies (Dec Only)

Christmas Sprankle Cookies (Dec Only)

Regular price From $7.25

Regular price Sale price From $7.25
Unit price per
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies

Gingerbread Molasses Cookies

Regular price From $7.25

Regular price Sale price From $7.25
Unit price per
Take & Bake Savory Quiche

Take & Bake Savory Quiche

Regular price $30.00

Regular price Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Mini Cupcakes: Nov/Dec

Mini Cupcakes: Nov/Dec

Regular price $18.00

Regular price Sale price $18.00
Unit price per