Online orders need at least 2 days' notice. Need something quick? Walk-in or call during open hours!
Common Questions
Search 0 Basket
0

Shop Online

HOW TO USE OUR "ONLINE SHOP":

+ Pickups are available during open hours (Wed-Sat).

+ In-store menu is usually the same as preorder menu.

+ Need it sooner than 2 days out? Or further than 4 weeks? Contact us to see what's available!

Seasonal Specials

Reindeer Bundt Cake: December Special
Reindeer Bundt Cake: December Special
$39.00
Peppermint Patty Pie: December Special
Peppermint Patty Pie: December Special
$29.00
Family Favorites Cookie Platter
Family Favorites Cookie Platter
From $43.00
Gingerbread Folks: December Special
Gingerbread Folks: December Special
From $12.75
Holiday Party Package (in person private event)
Holiday Party Package (in person private event)
$495.00
Deck the Halls- Decorated Cake
Deck the Halls- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Santa Baby Cake: December Special
Santa Baby Cake: December Special
From $37.00
Customize & order
Christmas Sprankle Cookies: December Special
Christmas Sprankle Cookies: December Special
From $6.75
Key Lime Pie: December Special
Key Lime Pie: December Special
$29.00
Evergreen Dream - Decorated Cake
Evergreen Dream - Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies
From $6.75
Snowy Woods- Decorated Cake
Snowy Woods- Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Santa Baby Cupcakes: December Special
Santa Baby Cupcakes: December Special
From $18.50
Festive Lights- Decorated Cake
Festive Lights- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Take & Bake Seasonal Fruit Crisp
Take & Bake Seasonal Fruit Crisp
$17.00
O' Christmas Tree- Decorated Cake
O' Christmas Tree- Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Take & Bake Savory Quiche
Take & Bake Savory Quiche
$30.00
Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake
Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake
From $105.00
Customize & order

Cakes

Prozac Cake
Prozac Cake
From $37.00
Customize & order
Plain Jane Cake
Plain Jane Cake
From $37.00
Customize & order
Strawberry Fields Forever Cake
Strawberry Fields Forever Cake
From $39.00
Customize & order
Truman Capote Cake
Truman Capote Cake
From $37.00
Customize & order
Classic Cake
Classic Cake
From $37.00
Customize & order
Lemon Zinger Cake
Lemon Zinger Cake
From $39.00
Customize & order
Red Velvet Cake
Red Velvet Cake
From $39.00
Customize & order
Mini Cake
Mini Cake
From $25.00
Festive Sprankle Toppings
Festive Sprankle Toppings
$0.00
Santa Baby Cake: December Special
Santa Baby Cake: December Special
From $37.00
Customize & order
Reindeer Bundt Cake: December Special
Reindeer Bundt Cake: December Special
$39.00

Decorated Cakes

Signature Swirl- Tiered Cake
Signature Swirl- Tiered Cake
From $165.00
Customize & order
Twilight Flower Burst - Decorated Cake
Twilight Flower Burst - Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Rosettes All Over- Decorated Cake
Rosettes All Over- Decorated Cake
From $35.00
Customize & order
Mod Daisies- Decorated Cake
Mod Daisies- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Swiss Dot- Tiered Cake
Swiss Dot- Tiered Cake
From $185.00
Customize & order
Cherry Basket - Decorated Cake
Cherry Basket - Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Kapow! - Decorated Cake
Kapow! - Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Rainbow Revelry- Decorated Cake
Rainbow Revelry- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Romantic Ruffles- Tiered Cake
Romantic Ruffles- Tiered Cake
From $185.00
Customize & order
Sunrise Flower Burst - Decorated Cake
Sunrise Flower Burst - Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Swiss Dot Multicolor- Decorated Cake
Swiss Dot Multicolor- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Birthday Bash- Decorated Cake
Birthday Bash- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Buttercream Blessings - Decorated Cake
Buttercream Blessings - Decorated Cake
From $65.00
Customize & order
Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake
Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake
From $105.00
Customize & order
Grand Graduation- Decorated Cake
Grand Graduation- Decorated Cake
From $60.00
Customize & order
Gender Reveal- Decorated Cake
Gender Reveal- Decorated Cake
From $50.00
Customize & order
Rustic Romance- Tiered Cake
Rustic Romance- Tiered Cake
From $185.00
Customize & order
O' Christmas Tree- Decorated Cake
O' Christmas Tree- Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Deck the Halls- Decorated Cake
Deck the Halls- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Snowy Woods- Decorated Cake
Snowy Woods- Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order
Festive Lights- Decorated Cake
Festive Lights- Decorated Cake
From $40.00
Customize & order
Dino Party- Decorated Cake
Dino Party- Decorated Cake
From $55.00
Customize & order
Evergreen Dream - Decorated Cake
Evergreen Dream - Decorated Cake
From $45.00
Customize & order

Cupcakes

Prozac Cupcakes
Prozac Cupcakes
From $18.50
Plain Jane Cupcakes
Plain Jane Cupcakes
From $18.50
Truman Capote Cupcakes
Truman Capote Cupcakes
From $18.50
Strawberry Fields Forever Cupcakes
Strawberry Fields Forever Cupcakes
From $18.50
Classic Cupcakes
Classic Cupcakes
From $18.50
Lemon Zinger Cupcakes
Lemon Zinger Cupcakes
From $18.50
Red Velvet Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cupcakes
From $18.50
Mini Cupcakes
Mini Cupcakes
$18.00
DIY Cupcake Kit
DIY Cupcake Kit
$22.00
Festive Sprankle Toppings
Festive Sprankle Toppings
$0.00
Santa Baby Cupcakes: December Special
Santa Baby Cupcakes: December Special
From $18.50

More treats

Brown Butter Crispy Rice Treats
Brown Butter Crispy Rice Treats
From $7.50
Shady Wake Pie
Shady Wake Pie
$29.00
Deluxe Chocolate Chip Cookies
Deluxe Chocolate Chip Cookies
From $6.75
Vanilla Bean Wafers
Vanilla Bean Wafers
$7.25
Cocoa Crackle Pie
Cocoa Crackle Pie
$25.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars
Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars
From $6.75
Jan's Famous Toffee Bark
Jan's Famous Toffee Bark
$9.00
Banana Puddin'
Banana Puddin'
$30.00
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies
From $6.75
Oreo Puddin'
Oreo Puddin'
$30.00
Coconut Macaroons
Coconut Macaroons
$11.25
Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookies
Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookies
From $6.75
DIY Butter Cookie Kit
DIY Butter Cookie Kit
$27.00
Oatmeal Everything Cookies
Oatmeal Everything Cookies
From $7.75
Take & Bake: Johnny Appleseed Pie
Take & Bake: Johnny Appleseed Pie
$30.00
Key Lime Pie: December Special
Key Lime Pie: December Special
$29.00
Christmas Sprankle Cookies: December Special
Christmas Sprankle Cookies: December Special
From $6.75
Peppermint Patty Pie: December Special
Peppermint Patty Pie: December Special
$29.00
Gingerbread Folks: December Special
Gingerbread Folks: December Special
From $12.75
Savory Snackers
Savory Snackers
$7.00

Take & bake

Take & Bake: Chicken Pot Pie
Take & Bake: Chicken Pot Pie
$30.00
Take & Bake Savory Quiche
Take & Bake Savory Quiche
$30.00
Take & Bake: Buttermilk Biscuits
Take & Bake: Buttermilk Biscuits
$15.00
Take & Bake Cookies
Take & Bake Cookies
From $17.00
Take & Bake Seasonal Fruit Crisp
Take & Bake Seasonal Fruit Crisp
$17.00
Take & Bake: All-Butter Crust
Take & Bake: All-Butter Crust
$10.00
Take & Bake: Ginger Scones
Take & Bake: Ginger Scones
$9.00
Take & Bake: Johnny Appleseed Pie
Take & Bake: Johnny Appleseed Pie
$30.00

Gifts

Muddy's Gift Card
Muddy's Gift Card
From $10.00
Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription
Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription
From $68.00
Birthday Candles
Birthday Candles
$5.00
Muddy's Tee Shirt
Muddy's Tee Shirt
$25.00
Muddy's Sweatshirt
Muddy's Sweatshirt
$40.00
Aprons
Aprons
From $25.00
Muddy's Drinkware
Muddy's Drinkware
From $16.00
Muddy's Baking Mixes
Muddy's Baking Mixes
From $10.00
Mom's Spiced Tea Mix
Mom's Spiced Tea Mix
$11.75
Muddy's Ball Cap
Muddy's Ball Cap
$25.00

Classes

Holiday Party Package (in person private event)
Holiday Party Package (in person private event)
$495.00
Birthday Party Package (in person private event)
Birthday Party Package (in person private event)
More Info
Private Group Bake-a-long Class (in-person or virtual)
Private Group Bake-a-long Class (in-person or virtual)
More Info
Private Group Work/Life Class
Private Group Work/Life Class
More Info